top of page

Challenging Heroes at A Red Orchid is Stunning

Angela Allyn
10 hours ago
3 min read

You know you are up for quite a night in the theatre when you are told in the lobby that the play you are about to see is two hours without intermission and there will be gunshots, vomit, haze, strong language and intense controversial themes.  Heroes of the Fourth Turning at A Red Orchid Theatre delivers all of the above– and also an intellectual and visceral journey into philosophical Catholic Conservatism in the wilderness. It’s way smarter than any Fox News.  


Playwright Will Arbery, who The New Yorker calls the playwright of the moment, takes you to a dark extremely uncomfortable place here. I don’t just mean the play’s time and location: near midnight prior to an eclipse in Wyoming, in a rustic and run down cabin where the culture wars are arming themselves. Alumni of a tiny Catholic liberal arts college that was never politically liberal gather to celebrate a well loved professor who has been inducted as president.  


Buckle up. This show is going to take you on a rocky not so pretty journey. The thing is, director and AROT ensemble member dado has made a career out of pulling out the most difficult parts of our humanity for a compassionate though never tidy look see. Whether it was the 1995 production of Tracers, her award winning 2017 Simpatico,the fluid splashed 2018 rendition of Phoebe in Winter or her original scattered meat experience of the Little Match Girl Passion  dado challenges the audience to look and listen to parts of themselves that they would rather avoid. She does not pull her punches, and the actors she assembles go distances rarely seen. There is an undeniable fearlessness in a dado show, but it's so empathically done that even when the subject matter scares the poop out of you, you are able to keep watching.  dado paired with Arbery gives us a production that will grab your mind like a pit bull and shake you. 


This play may terrify you because the ironclad faith of every character’s mission is unshakeable, and because the characters are really smart and quoting all the right philosophers, and because this is a war they must win or they will die trying. And they are actually armed. They make it clear it’s a war that won’t be ending.   


Finally,though only one of the characters is outwardly unhinged: the drunken, self loathing Kevin, played with abandon by Beck Nolan, all of them are unnerving to anyone living in the bubble of Chicago.  Theresa, played by Isa Grofsorean, has assimilated mainstream corporate influencing as only an evangelist can. Still she’s one contradiction away from an explosion.  There is Gina, the new college president that they are there to celebrate, as brought to life by Kirsten Fitzgerald, powerful and threatening in her maternal control. There’s that horrible intermittent screaming squeal out in this wilderness as if this universe is pulling itself apart. 


I am truly grateful I saw this play after the election. Had I seen it before the vote count was in, my mental health would have taken a deep dive.  Now seeing this play, it bolsters my sense that if we want a future there is an insane amount of work to be done, and also, there are people out there with stellar minds who will not be swayed or convinced or uprooted from their profound belief in a world I could not live in. Yet we all must live here together.This play holds no answers. 


This is a challenging night of theater because of what you will think about as it's happening and after it happens. It’s also so physically close in the tiny storefront of AROT that you are truly in the middle of Grant Sabin’s perfectly distressed set.  Go see this show.  


This season’s theme at A Red Orchid Theatre is World On Fire– this play kicks off season 34 with a molotov cocktail. Heroes of the Fourth Turning is playing Thursdays through Sundays through December 6, 2026 at A Red Orchid Theatre, 1531 N Wells Street in Chicago’s Old Town. For tickets and information go to https://aredorchidtheatre.org/shows/heroes-of-the-fourth-turning/


Comments


773 944 0119 but email at the address above is always preferred.

bottom of page